Contact Your Carrier – Claims & Billing Directory

When you need a claim number, billing phone, or online portal fast, this page puts carrier contacts in one place. Vargas & Vargas Insurance is your first call for advice, but if it’s after hours—or a carrier requires you to contact them directly—use the directory below to reach the right team quickly. Our Dorchester office at 1133 Washington St serves as your local advocate before, during, and after a claim.

When to Call Your Carrier vs. Vargas & Vargas

Call us for coverage questions, claim guidance, paperwork, certificates, and policy changes—we’ll advise you and, when appropriate, stay on the line while connecting you to the carrier. After hours, use the carrier phone numbers and links listed here, then update our team the next business day so we can follow through.

Woman with red hair on phone, using laptop while lying on a bed, notepad open.

Claims & Billing: Quick Steps

  1. Make sure everyone is safe; call emergency services if needed.

  2. Prevent further damage (temporary measures when safe).

  3. Gather policy details and photos.

  4. Start the claim with your carrier using the directory below; note your claim number.

  5. Tell our agency so we can advocate for you and coordinate next steps.

Carrier Directory

Our carrier partners include regional and national companies with dedicated claims and billing lines, such as Arbella, Commerce (MAPFRE), Massachusetts Property Insurance (MPIUA), New London County Mutual, Norfolk & Dedham, Palomar, Pilgrim, Plymouth Rock, Safety, Travelers, and Vermont Mutual. Each card below includes customer service and claims links/phones for quick access.

Arbella Insurance logo: blue ship icon above

Arbella Insurance


Customer Service: 800-272-3552

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

MAPFRE Insurance logo: red

Commerce


Customer Service: 800-221-1605

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Logo for Mass Property Insurance: house graphic with arrow, and text.

Mass Property


Customer Service: 617-723-3800

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

NLC Insurance Companies logo: white

New London County Mutual


Customer Service: 800-962-0800

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Red

Norfolk and Dedham


Customer Service: 800-688-1825

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Palomar logo: teal and green geometric design with the word

Palomar


Customer Service: 619-567-5290

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Logo of Pilgrim, with a blue square icon and the word

Pilgrim


Customer Service: 800-721-8294

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Logo for Plymouth Rock Assurance with blue geometric shape. Text: Plymouth Rock, assurance.

Plymouth Rock


Customer Service: 844-346-1225

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Logo: Blue circle with a road graphic; text

Safety


Customer Service: 617-951-0600

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Travelers logo with black text and a red umbrella over the letter

Travelers


Customer Service: 800-252-4633

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Logo for Vermont Mutual Insurance Group:

Vermont Mutual


Customer Service: 800-435-0397

Claims: Visit Website

Website: Visit Website

Tips Before You Call

Have your policy number, contact info, photos, and a brief summary of what happened. For auto, note driver, location, and police report details. For property, list damaged rooms/items and any steps you took to prevent further loss. We’ll help you with documentation and next steps once the claim is opened.

Need Something Else?

If you don’t see your company listed or the link doesn’t work, contact Vargas & Vargas Insurance and we’ll point you in the right direction immediately.

We’re Here to Help—Anytime

During business hours, call or text our Dorchester team; after hours, start with the carrier, then leave us a message or email so we can follow up first thing.