The Psychology Behind Underinsurance: A Shared Experience


Carlos Vargas | Aug 07 2025 12:00

A Shared Experience of Hesitation

Have you ever found yourself thinking, "I really need to get life insurance," yet never quite following through? You're far from alone. Many of us have been in this position, feeling the intention but not taking action. This hesitation is common, and it's not just about procrastination. There's more beneath the surface.

Understanding Our Psychological Tendencies

It turns out that our minds are wired in ways that can unintentionally lead us to delay purchasing life insurance. By understanding these psychological tendencies, we can start taking confident steps toward financial security. Let's explore three of these tendencies that might be influencing your decisions.

Normalcy Bias: The Expectation of Continuity

We often succumb to what's known as a normalcy bias —the belief that things will continue as they are. This bias can prevent us from preparing for unlikely emergencies. You might think, "Nothing has gone wrong so far, so why would it now?" This line of thought can delay essential preparations, like buying insurance, simply because things have always been fine.

Optimism Bias: The "It Won't Happen to Me" Fallacy

There's also the optimism bias , a cognitive bias that leads many to believe they're less likely than others to experience serious situations, such as illness or loss. This belief can result in delaying or avoiding life insurance because we see ourselves as exceptions to the rule. While positivity is beneficial, it's essential to keep realism in check.

Cost Misperception: The Overestimated Deterrent

A major deterrent to purchasing life insurance is the cost misperception. Did you know that 72% of Americans overestimate the cost of life insurance? This overestimation can become a significant roadblock, even though policies are often more affordable than we assume. Understanding the true cost can open doors to practical, cost-effective solutions.

Taking the First Step

Recognizing these psychological patterns is the first step toward overcoming them. Now that you understand why you might have been hesitant, consider reaching out for a quote, researching your policy options, or simply starting a conversation about life insurance today. The road to financial security begins with a single, informed step.